You Catch More Flies with Honey: Why Positivity Wins Interviews

You Catch More Flies with Honey: Why Positivity Wins Interviews

You Catch More Flies with Honey:

Why Positivity Wins Interviews

There’s an old saying that you catch more flies with honey than vinegar. In recruitment, we see the proof of it every single day. Skills and experience get you noticed, but how you come across often decides whether you get the job.

The simple truth is that people like happy people. Employers aren’t just hiring a CV. They’re choosing someone they’ll work alongside every day, and they want that person to be pleasant, positive and easy to work with.

First Impressions Start Before You Walk In

Your first impression doesn’t begin when you sit down for the interview. It starts with your first email, your first phone call, or the way you greet the receptionist at the front desk.

  • Emails: be friendly and polite. A warm greeting, a thank you and a professional sign-off go a long way. Avoid SHOUTY CAPS and remember punctuation.
  • Phone calls: answer clearly, smile while you speak (people can hear it), and be courteous even if the timing is inconvenient.
  • Everyone you meet: the receptionist, the security guard and the person who makes you coffee may all be asked what they thought of you. Treat everyone with the same respect.

In the Interview: Smile, Shake Hands, Be Present

The basics matter more than people think.

  • Smile. It instantly makes you seem approachable and confident, even if you’re nervous.
  • Offer a firm, friendly handshake and make eye contact.
  • Be positive. Talk about what you’ve learned and what you’re looking forward to, rather than what went wrong.
  • Show genuine interest. Ask questions about the company and the role. Enthusiasm is attractive to employers.
  • Mind your manners. Say please and thank you, don’t interrupt, and put your phone away. (If you have to take it in with you, on silent with vibrate switched off.)

Being positive doesn’t mean being fake. It means choosing to present the best version of yourself.

Why Being Demanding Rarely Works

We understand that job hunting can be stressful and frustrating. But being demanding, impatient or difficult almost never gets you the result you want.

Candidates who insist on immediate answers, argue about the process or why they were not shortlisted, or speak rudely to consultants or employers quickly get remembered for the wrong reasons. Even if you’re the most qualified person on paper, an employer may decide you’d be hard to manage or wouldn’t fit into their team.

Positivity Is a Skill You Can Practise

Not everyone is naturally bubbly, and that’s okay. Likability isn’t about being the loudest person in the room. It’s about being warm, respectful and pleasant to deal with. A few habits help:

  • Prepare well, so you feel calmer and more confident on the day.
  • Reframe negatives: instead of “I hated my last job”, try “I’m looking for a role where I can grow”.
  • Follow up with a short, friendly thank-you message after your interview.
  • If you don’t get the job, respond graciously. How you handle disappointment says a lot about you.

Be Kind

And finally- Be Kind.  You may be frustrated and stressed, but you have no idea what the interviewer or employer has going on, that may prevent them from giving you feedback.

We’re Here to Help

At RESOURCE Recruitment, we prepare every candidate for their interviews, including how to make a great first impression. If you’re looking for your next opportunity, visit www.2r.co.za to view our current vacancies.

Remember: a smile costs nothing, but it could be what lands you the job.

If you are thinking of recruiting, have a look at our RESOURCEful Background Checks, and our latest Top Candidates!

W

RESOURCE Recruitment Rates: What It Costs and How It Works

RESOURCE Recruitment Rates: What It Costs and How It Works

RESOURCE Recruitment Rates: What It Costs and How It Works

In our last post we explained how employment agencies work and what RESOURCE Recruitment does for both candidates and employers. This time we’re talking money: what our fees are, how they’re calculated, and which option might suit your business best.

We believe in being upfront about costs. There are no hidden extras, and you’ll always know what you’re paying for before we start.

First, a Reminder for Job Seekers

All of the fees below are paid by the employer. Candidates never pay us anything, and in South Africa it’s illegal for an agency to charge a job seeker. If anyone asks you for money to find you work, it’s a scam.

How Our Fees Are Calculated

Our permanent placement fees are worked out as a percentage of the employee’s starting annual salary. What makes up the package is agreed with you when you give us the go-ahead to recruit, so there are no surprises later.

To keep things simple, all the examples below are based on a monthly salary of R10 000. All fees are quoted excluding VAT.

Option One: Straight Permanent Placement

This is the most common option. We find, screen and present the right candidate, you employ them directly, and you pay a once-off placement fee.

  • Fee: 12% of the annual salary
  • Example: R10 000 x 12 months x 12% = R14 400 + VAT
  • Invoiced: on the day the employee starts work
  • Guarantee: 3 months

How the guarantee works

If the person we placed resigns, or you have to let them go because they can’t meet the competencies of the role, within the first three months, we’ll find you a replacement candidate at no extra cost.

A few conditions apply:

  • The invoice must be paid within 14 days of the employee starting.
  • The guarantee covers one replacement candidate.
  • You need to let us know within 48 hours of the employee’s last day.
  • The employer must have followed fair labour practice in line with the Basic Conditions of Employment Act and the Labour Relations Act.

Option Two: Temp (or Probation) to Permanent

This option suits employers who’d like to see someone in the role before committing to a permanent appointment.

The candidate goes onto your payroll from day one. You pay us a monthly agency fee while they work for you. If you decide to make them permanent, the agency fees you’ve already paid are deducted from the placement fee.

  • Monthly agency fee: 20% of the monthly salary, so R10 000 x 20% = R2 000 + VAT per month
  • Placement fee if they go permanent: 13% of the annual salary, so R10 000 x 12 x 13% = R15 600 + VAT
  • Deduction: up to three months of agency fees (in this example, up to R6 000) comes off the placement fee

Example: you employ the candidate on this basis for three months and then offer them a permanent position. You’ll have paid R6 000 in agency fees, so the balance of the placement fee is R15 600 less R6 000 = R9 600 + VAT.

If you decide not to make the candidate permanent, you simply stop there. There’s no further fee, but please note there’s no guarantee and no refund of the agency fees on this option.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the cost if we don’t end of employing one of RESOURCE recruitment’s candidates?

There is no fee.  Unless one of RESOURCE recruitments candidates is offered the position, accepts and starts, there is no fee.  Placement fees are invoiced only when the candidate has started.

What does the placement fee include?

All RESOURCE recruitments candidates are personally interviewed by a consultant, telephonic references are conducted; and social media, ITC (credit), fraud, criminal checks and qualification checks are done as appropriate.

Can you assist with contracts of employment and letters of offer?

We are here to assist you every step of the way, with free template letters of offer, contracts of employment, template policies and a variety of other tools, such as performance appraisal templates.

Can we still advertise the position ourselves, and use other employment agencies?

Absolutely!

 

If you are thinking of recruiting, have a look at our RESOURCEful Background Checks, and our latest Top Candidates!

W

How Employment Agencies Work – and How RESOURCE Recruitment Works for You

How Employment Agencies Work

How Employment Agencies Work – and How RESOURCE Recruitment Works for You

Whether you’re looking for your next job or your next great hire, it helps to know what an employment agency actually does, who pays for it, and what you should expect along the way. After more than 20 years of placing people across KwaZulu-Natal, here’s how we do things at RESOURCE Recruitment.

Part One: For Job Seekers

You should never pay to find a job.  Let’s start with the most important point. A legitimate employment agency will never charge you, the job seeker, a cent. In South Africa it is illegal for an employment agency to charge work seekers a fee for finding them work or placing them in a job.

If anyone asks you for money to register, to “secure” an interview, to process your CV, or to guarantee you a position, it is a scam. Please don’t pay. Walk away, and warn your friends and family too. Sadly, job seekers are often targeted because people are desperate for work, and scammers know it.

At RESOURCE recruitment, our services to candidates are completely free. Our fees are paid by the employer, our client, once a placement is made.

We partner with you

We don’t see candidates as names on a database. We see you as a partner. Our job is to help you put your best foot forward and find a role where you can genuinely thrive. From the moment you start working with us, we’re there to help you with:

  • Your CV: making sure it’s clear, professional and honest, and that it shows your experience and strengths properly.
  • Interview skills: getting you ready for the interview itself, from how to present yourself to how to talk about your experience with confidence.
  • Background on the company and role: we tell you about the business you’re meeting and what they’re looking for, so you walk in prepared.
  • Tricky questions: we help you get ready for the challenging ones, like “Why did you leave your last job?” or “What’s your biggest weakness?”, so you can answer honestly and professionally.

Feedback, every time

One of the most frustrating things about job hunting is applying and never hearing back. At RESOURCE recruitment, every candidate who applies or goes for an interview through us receives feedback. Whether it’s good news or not this time, you’ll know where you stand, and you’ll get something useful to take into your next opportunity.

Support that doesn’t stop when you get the job

Getting the offer is just the beginning. We walk with you through your first six months of employment. We follow up weekly in the early days, while everything is new, and then monthly as you settle in. If something isn’t working, we’re there to help sort it out before it becomes a bigger problem.

And it doesn’t end at six months. Many of our candidates have worked with us for years as their careers have grown. We see it as a lifetime partnership: supporting you not just into a job, but through your career.

Part Two: For Employers

A skills shortage, not just a job shortage

It sounds strange in a country with South Africa’s unemployment rate, but many employers are facing more of a skills shortage than a shortage of applicants. Posting a vacancy may bring in hundreds of CVs, yet finding someone with the right specialised skills, the right work ethic and the right cultural fit for your team is a different story altogether.

That’s where a good agency earns its place.

Reach that goes beyond the job boards

RESOURCE Recruitment has been a leader in e-recruitment in KZN for years. Alongside the standard job portals and advertising channels, we reach candidates through:

  • A large and active following on Facebook and LinkedIn
  • TikTok and other platforms to connect with younger talent
  • An extensive email database
  • A large WhatsApp vacancy alert database

This means your vacancy reaches people who are actively looking, as well as strong candidates who may not be scrolling through job boards at all. Combined with more than 20 years in the market and a well-established candidate database, we have a strong grasp of who’s out there and what it takes to attract them.

Every candidate properly screened

We don’t send CVs blindly. Nobody is sent to an interview with you unless they’ve been personally interviewed by one of our consultants. Every candidate is also reference checked telephonically.

Through our dedicated screening division, RESOURCEful Background Checks, we can also run ITC (credit), criminal and qualification checks, so you have a fuller and more reliable picture before you make a decision.

Not just putting bums in seats

We partner with our clients in the same way we partner with our candidates. Before we start a search, we take the time to understand what you need now, what the role will need in the long term, and who will genuinely fit into your company. A placement only counts as a success for us if it works for both you and the candidate.

Ready to Get Started?

Whether you’re looking for work or looking to hire, we’d love to help. Visit www.2r.co.za to view current vacancies, register as a candidate, or get in touch with our team about your recruitment needs.

Remember: a genuine agency will never ask a job seeker for money.

Why Credit Checks Matter — and What Should Actually Worry You

Why Credit Checks Matter — and What Should Actually Worry You

Why Credit Checks Matter — and What Should Actually Worry You

A companion to our earlier post on reading a credit report fairly. This one makes the other half of the case: why, for the right roles, skipping the check is a serious mistake.

We have written before about how to read a credit report fairly, and about the danger of treating any adverse listing as an automatic disqualification. That remains our position.

But there is a second failure mode, and in smaller businesses it is far more common than over-reaction. It is not running the check at all.

For roles that genuinely involve cash, finances or company assets, a credit check is one of the most cost-effective risk controls available to you — and the South African numbers make the case better than I can.

The scale of the problem

The Association of Certified Fraud Examiners publishes Occupational Fraud: A Report to the Nations, the most comprehensive study of workplace fraud available. The findings for South Africa in the 2026 edition are not comfortable reading.

  • South Africa recorded 123 of the 397 occupational fraud cases reported across Sub-Saharan Africa — the highest number on the continent, ahead of Nigeria on 64 and Kenya on 33.
  • The region recorded a median loss of roughly R1.7 million per case.
  • Corruption was the most common scheme in Sub-Saharan Africa, appearing in 56% of cases.
  • 58% of regional cases involved more than one perpetrator — collusion is higher here than the global average.
  • Managers accounted for 46% of cases in the region, employees 37%, and owner-executives 14%.
  • Globally, a typical organisation loses around 5% of its annual revenue to fraud, and the average case runs for about twelve months before it is detected.
  • More than half of cases globally arose from either an absence of internal controls or the override of controls that existed.

And the recovery picture is the part that should concentrate the mind. In Sub-Saharan Africa, only 12% of organisations recovered all of their losses. Forty percent recovered some. Forty-nine percent recovered nothing at all.

That last figure is the whole argument for screening. Prevention is not merely cheaper than recovery — for roughly half of affected businesses, recovery does not happen.

Fraud at the application stage is rising too

The Southern African Fraud Prevention Service has tracked a sharp increase in fraud reported by its members, including a 600% rise in reported incidents in 2022 compared with 2018, and a further 32% increase in 2023.

More directly relevant to hiring, the SAFPS has linked rising unemployment to a documented increase in employment application fraud — people falsifying documentation to make themselves more appealing to employers. Recent verification data from the industry suggests roughly one in five education verification checks turns up a discrepancy or outright fraud.

It is worth candidates knowing that a confirmed listing with the SAFPS is not a slap on the wrist. It can affect access to finance for years afterwards.

So what is a credit check actually for?

Let me be precise, because this is where employers get muddled.

A credit report does not tell you whether someone is honest. It cannot. What it does is give you visibility of financial pressure — and financial pressure is the single most consistent precondition in occupational fraud.

The classic model of workplace fraud has three elements: pressure, opportunity and rationalisation. An employer controls opportunity through internal controls and segregation of duties. Rationalisation is largely about culture. Pressure is the element you can actually see in advance, and a credit report is the clearest window onto it.

That is the honest case for the check. Not “this person has a judgment, therefore they will steal” — which is both wrong and unfair — but “this person is under significant and escalating financial pressure, and I am about to give them unsupervised access to cash, so let me make sure my controls are sound and let me have a conversation.”

What genuinely constitutes a red flag

Concealment. This is the most important one and it has nothing to do with the debt itself. If a candidate declares nothing and the report shows three judgments, the issue is not the judgments. It is that they chose to conceal them from a prospective employer while applying for a role of financial trust. Someone who says upfront that they went through a hard patch in 2021 and have been settling it since is telling you something reassuring.

Escalation. Not the total, but the trajectory. New defaults in the last six months, accounts moving into arrears now, listings that are still accumulating. Current, worsening pressure is a different risk from a resolved historical difficulty.

Lifestyle inconsistent with income. ACFE research has consistently found living beyond one’s means to be the most commonly observed behavioural warning sign in occupational fraud cases. Where a credit report shows debt service obligations that plainly exceed what the salary can carry, that is a meaningful signal.

Emoluments attachment orders. A garnishee against salary tells you two things at once: creditors have gone to court, and a portion of the pay you are about to offer is already committed. It also materially affects whether your offer is actually viable for the candidate.

Judgments or listings connected to dishonesty. Most consumer debt says nothing about integrity. A judgment arising from fraud, theft or misrepresentation is a different matter entirely, and belongs in a different category from a defaulted store account.

A SAFPS listing. This is not a credit stress signal. It indicates a confirmed fraud case supported by evidence, and it should be treated as a serious finding.

Mismatch with the CV. Credit reports carry employment information. Where the employer or dates on the report do not match the CV, you have a discrepancy to resolve — and, as we covered in our post on CV honesty, discrepancies rarely stay isolated.

And what should not worry you

For balance, because this is where the earlier post applies.

  • A single old judgment, settled, with a clean record since.
  • A cluster of listings around one date with an explicable cause — a retrenchment, an illness, a business that closed in 2020.
  • Active debt review. This shows someone confronting a problem within a formal structure and complying with it. It is closer to a positive signal than a negative one.
  • Arrears on a single account, particularly where a dispute is recorded.
  • Adverse history on a candidate for a role with no financial exposure — which you should not have run the check on in the first place.

The benefit that is easy to miss

There is one more argument that rarely gets made.

A well-run screening process protects honest candidates too. When employers cannot verify anything, they fall back on gut feel, on who presents well, on informal networks and personal referral. That disadvantages exactly the people who have no network and nothing but a genuine record to offer.

Verification is what allows an employer to take a chance on someone unfamiliar. It is the mechanism by which an unknown candidate with a real qualification and a genuine history can compete with a known quantity.

What Psychometric Tests Actually Tell You — and What They Do Not

What Psychometric Tests Actually Tell You — and What They Do Not

Used properly, assessments are one of the most useful tools in hiring. Used by someone unqualified to read them, they are worse than useless.

Psychometric assessment is the part of the hiring process that generates the most confidence and the least understanding.

I have watched an employer decline an excellent candidate because a report said they scored low on “extroversion” for a role that involved almost no client contact. I have watched another hire someone on the strength of a glowing profile without noticing that the assessment measured personality preference and said nothing whatsoever about ability. Both employers felt they had made an evidence-based decision. Neither had.

The problem is not the tests. Properly chosen and properly interpreted, assessments add real predictive value that interviews alone cannot. The problem is what happens between the report being generated and someone acting on it.

First, the legal position — because it is stricter than most employers realise

In South Africa, psychometric testing is not something an employer may simply buy and administer.

Section 8 of the Employment Equity Act 55 of 1998 prohibits psychological testing and similar assessment of an employee unless the test has been scientifically shown to be valid and reliable, can be applied fairly to all employees, and is not biased against any employee or group. All three conditions must be met, not just one.

Under the Health Professions Act 56 of 1974, only practitioners registered with the HPCSA may perform psychological acts — and administering, scoring, interpreting or reporting on a psychological test is a psychological act. A person without the appropriate registration who interprets a psychological assessment is acting unlawfully.

What the different instruments actually measure

A great deal of confusion comes from treating “psychometrics” as one category. It is not. The instruments measure fundamentally different things, and they do not carry equal predictive weight.

Ability and aptitude tests

Numerical reasoning, verbal reasoning, abstract or logical reasoning, mechanical comprehension. These measure capability — how well someone processes a certain kind of information under time pressure.

These are the most robust predictors of job performance available, particularly for roles with genuine cognitive complexity.

Personality and behavioural preference instruments

These measure preference and typical behaviour, not capability. A person who scores as introverted is not incapable of presenting to a boardroom; they are indicating that it is not where they naturally gravitate and that it may cost them more energy.

Integrity and honesty assessments

Used widely in cash-handling and retail environments. They can be useful as one input, but they produce false positives, and no responsible practitioner would treat a result as evidence that a particular individual is dishonest.

Emotional intelligence and situational judgement

Increasingly used for leadership roles. Situational judgement tests in particular can be genuinely predictive when they have been built around the actual role rather than bought off the shelf.

Where it goes wrong

Assessment reports are written in a technical register that looks accessible. Words like “dominance”, “conscientiousness” and “anxiety” have specific measured meanings that do not match their everyday use. A layperson reading a report is not reading what the report says — they are reading what those words mean in ordinary English, which is something else entirely.

Norms and context do not fit the population. Many instruments in use in South Africa were developed in Western contexts and normed on populations that look very little like ours. In a country with eleven official languages and enormous variation in educational opportunity, an assessment administered in a candidate’s second or third language can measure language proficiency while appearing to measure reasoning. This is precisely what section 8 is aimed at, and it is a live fairness issue rather than a theoretical one.

An assessment is one input alongside the interview, the references, the work history and any technical testing. When a report contradicts three strong references and a solid track record, the sensible response is to ask why — not to discard the evidence of actual performance in favour of the instrument.

Where they are genuinely powerful

Used well, it does things no interview can.

It tests competencies an interview cannot reach. Interviews measure how well someone interviews. A structured reasoning assessment measures reasoning. For roles where analytical capability genuinely matters, this closes a real gap — and it tends to help candidates who are capable but not naturally polished in an interview room.

It reduces bias rather than adding to it. A properly validated instrument applied consistently to every candidate is more objective than a series of unstructured conversations in which interviewers reliably favour people like themselves. This is one of the strongest arguments for assessment and it is rarely made.

It tells a manager how to manage this person. This is the most under-used output of the whole exercise. A good profile tells a new manager whether this person wants detailed direction or room to run, whether they will raise a problem early or try to solve it quietly first, how they are likely to respond to public feedback. That is enormously valuable in the first ninety days, and it is generally filed and forgotten the moment the offer is signed.

It supports development, not just selection. The same profile that informed the hire can inform a development plan, a promotion conversation or a succession decision two years later.

How to use assessment properly

  • Decide what you are trying to predict before you choose an instrument, not after.
  • Use a practitioner registered with the HPCSA to administer and interpret. This is a legal requirement, not best practice.
  • Ask the provider directly about validity, reliability and South African norms. A credible provider will answer without hesitation.
  • Results of tests can form the foundation of questions in an interview.
  • Give the candidate feedback.
  • Pass the useful part on to the hiring manager, and actually use it in onboarding.

The short version

A psychometric assessment is a measuring instrument. Like any instrument, it is only as good as the person reading it and the question it was chosen to answer.

Read by a qualified practitioner, matched to the role, and weighed alongside everything else you know, it will improve your hiring and give a new manager a genuine head start.

Read by an untrained eye, out of context, and treated as the final word, it will cost you good people — and you will never know it did, because the candidate you wrongly declined does not send you a report on how they performed elsewhere.

Turning a Reference into a Probation Plan

Turning a Reference into a Probation Plan

Turning a Reference into a Probation Plan

Part three of three on getting real value out of reference checks.

Most employers treat a reference check as a verdict. The reference is good, so you hire. The reference raises a concern, so you do not.

A Probation Period is a defined window in which an employer evaluates and develops a new employee against the requirements of the role, with the support and guidance to actually meet them. That is its purpose in law and in practice.

Which means a reference that surfaces a manageable concern is not a reason to walk away. It is a briefing note for the first three months.

A worked example

A referee tells you the candidate was strong technically, well liked, produced good work — but timekeeping was a persistent issue. Late in the mornings, occasionally late to meetings.

The reflexive response is to decline. There is a documented concern, and there are other candidates.

But consider what you have actually been handed. You have a specific, observable, entirely fixable behaviour, identified before day one, from someone with no reason to invent it

So you hire the person, and on day one you say something like this:

“Punctuality is a key requirement of this role, because the team briefing at eight is where the day gets allocated. I want to be direct with you that this is one of the things I will be assessing during your probation. Here is what I expect, here is how we will review it, and if anything is making it difficult, tell me early.”

Now look at what you have done. You have named the standard clearly. You have made it measurable. You have given the person a genuine chance to meet it. And you have created a fair, documented basis for the conversation that follows if they do not.

That is exactly what probation is for.

What belongs in a probation plan, and what does not

Not every concern can be handled this way, and it matters that you can tell the difference.

Suited to probation

  • Timekeeping and attendance.
  • Reporting and administrative discipline.
  • Communication style — too blunt, too indirect, does not escalate early enough.
  • Systems or process knowledge that can be trained.
  • Pace and volume of output where the previous environment differed.
  • Working independently versus needing direction.

What these have in common is that they are observable, they can be described in advance, and they are capable of improvement with clear expectations and support.

Not suited to probation

  • Findings of dishonesty, theft or fraud.
  • Any conduct issue involving harassment or safety.
  • A qualification the person does not hold and cannot obtain.
  • A core competency the role requires from day one with no realistic runway.

These are not development areas. Do not try to manage them through probation.

How to actually do it

Name it before they start. The single most common failure is hiring with a concern in mind and never mentioning it — then being frustrated at week six about something the employee was never told mattered. If it is important enough to weigh in the hiring decision, it is important enough to say out loud on day one.

Attach it to the role, not the person. “Punctuality is a key requirement of this position” is a statement about the job. “Your previous employer said you were always late” is an accusation, and it starts the relationship badly. You are also not obliged to disclose the source of a reference comment, and generally should not.

Make it measurable. “Improve your communication” is not something anyone can succeed at. “Send a written update to the team every Friday by midday” is.

Review it more than once. A single conversation at the end of three months is not a probation process. Schedule check-ins early enough that there is time to correct course.

Write it down. Both for fairness to the employee and because probation dismissals are procedurally scrutinised. Evidence that a standard was communicated, support was offered and the employee was given a genuine opportunity to improve is what distinguishes a defensible decision from an unfair one.

Offer support, not just scrutiny. Probation is meant to include guidance, training and counselling.

What this does for your hiring

There is a practical benefit here beyond fairness.

In a market this tight, employers who reject every candidate with a single documented imperfection are competing for an increasingly small pool of people. Meanwhile, capable candidates with one manageable flaw — the sort of flaw that appears on almost every honest reference — are being passed over repeatedly.

If you can identify which concerns are trainable and structure a proper probation around them, you can hire from a substantially wider field than your competitors.

The reference told you where to look. Probation is where you look.

That is a far better use of a phone call than a yes or a no.

Contact RESOURCEful at checks@2r.co.za for all your background checks!

RESOURCEful Background Checks — the screening division of RESOURCE Recruitment — verifies drivers’ licences, Professional Driving Permits, and driver accident histories for KZN employers, alongside our full range of pre-employment checks. Know who’s behind the wheel before they turn the key. 

 

Why Good Candidates Get Poor References

Why Good Candidates Get Poor References

Why Good Candidates Get Poor References

Part two of three on getting real value out of reference checks.

A lukewarm reference feels like a clear signal. Someone who worked with this person is not enthusiastic about them, and that seems like the kind of information you should act on.

Sometimes it is. But in over twenty years of making these calls, I have learnt that a poor reference frequently says as much about the person giving it as it does about the candidate — and if you cannot tell the difference, you will pass on good people.

Here are the situations I encounter most often.

The employer took the resignation personally

This one is more common than most people would expect, and it is rarely acknowledged.

A candidate resigns. The employer, particularly in a smaller business where the relationship was close, experiences it as a rejection rather than a career decision. Perhaps they had invested in this person. Perhaps they had made assumptions about loyalty. Perhaps the departure caused real operational pain.

Six weeks later, someone phones for a reference.

What comes back is technically accurate and noticeably cool. The referee is not lying — they are simply speaking from a position of residual hurt about a decision that had nothing to do with the candidate’s ability.

The signal to watch for is a reference where the factual answers are fine, the tone is flat, and no specific criticism is ever actually articulated, or is personal, rather than professional feedback.

A personality clash is being reported as a performance issue

Two people did not get on. It happens in every workplace. But when one of them is giving a reference on the other, the friction very often gets translated into the language of performance.

“We had different working styles” becomes “she was not a team player”. “He challenged my decisions” becomes “he was difficult to manage”.

The way through this is specificity. Ask what the person actually did. Behaviour can be assessed against your own environment; a characterisation cannot. A candidate who pushed back on decisions might have been genuinely obstructive — or might be exactly the person you need in a team that currently agrees with everything.

The referee barely knew them

You reach an HR representative who joined after the candidate left, or a manager who oversaw forty people and had limited direct contact.

What you get is cautious, non-committal and thin. It reads as reserved. It is actually just uninformed.

Always establish the working relationship early in the call. How closely did you work together, and for how long? A tepid reference from someone with minimal exposure to the candidate should carry almost no weight at all.

Company policy limits what can be said

Many larger organisations now restrict references to confirmation of dates and job title. Some prohibit any commentary at all.

This is not a hidden warning. It is a legal risk position, applied to everyone equally. Do not read a bare confirmation as reticence — but do note that it means this particular reference gives you very little, and you will need to weight your other checks accordingly.

The candidate was a poor fit rather than a poor employee

Someone who struggled in a rigid, process-heavy environment may be excellent in an agile one. Someone who underperformed under a manager who gave no direction may thrive under one who does. Someone whose role changed under them may have been managed out of a job they were originally good at.

A reference reports how the person performed in that context. It does not tell you how they will perform in yours. When you hear about difficulties, ask what the environment was like — and then ask yourself honestly whether your environment is the same one.

There was a difficult exit for reasons unrelated to their work

Retrenchments handled badly. Disputes over notice or final pay. A CCMA matter. Grievances raised before departure.

Any of these can sour the tone of a reference completely, while telling you almost nothing about how the person did their job. It is worth remembering that a candidate who raised a legitimate grievance may well be the person in the story who behaved correctly.

So what do you actually do?

Not “ignore bad references”. That would be the wrong lesson.

Weight them properly instead.

  • Always take at least two references, and preferably from different employers. One negative reference against two positive ones from comparable roles is an outlier. The same concern raised twice is a pattern.
  • Establish the relationship before you weigh the content. Closeness and recency determine how much a view is worth.
  • Press for behaviour. If a criticism cannot be reduced to something the person actually did, treat it as opinion.
  • Separate hard findings from soft ones. Dishonesty, theft and formal disciplinary findings sit in a different category and should not be discounted on the basis of a personality clash theory.

And keep the whole exercise in proportion. A reference is one input. Criminal and credit checks where the role warrants them, qualification verification, psychometric assessment and a properly structured second interview all exist for good reason.

In the final post in this series, I look at what to do when a reference raises something real but manageable — and how to use probation for the purpose it was actually designed for.

 

 

Reference Checks: Benefit of the Doubt, and Where It Ends

Reference Checks: Benefit of the Doubt, and Where It Ends

A closing piece on references. The first three posts argued for giving candidates a fair hearing. This one sets out the findings that should stop a hire.

Across three posts on reference checking, I have argued for generosity.

I have argued that much of a reference is subjective, that good candidates get poor references for reasons that have nothing to do with their work, and that a manageable concern is a briefing note for probation rather than grounds to decline.

But read together, those three posts risk leaving an impression I do not intend — that every negative reference can be explained away, and that a sufficiently open-minded employer should hire almost anyone.

That is not the argument. Some findings are genuine deal breakers, and an employer who talks themselves past them is not being fair-minded.

First, the principle

The distinction that matters is not positive versus negative. It is capability versus conduct, and record versus opinion.

Most of what makes a reference sound bad is opinion about capability or style — how someone worked, whether they were easy to manage, whether they fitted in. That material is contextual, it is genuinely contestable, and it deserves the benefit of the doubt.

Findings of conduct are different. They are matters of record, they were usually established through a process, and they do not become less true in a different environment.

Give the benefit of the doubt on style. Do not give it on conduct.

The deal breakers

Findings relating to dishonesty, theft or fraud. This is the clearest one. Where a former employer confirms a disciplinary finding involving dishonesty, that is a matter of record and it should end the process for any role involving trust — which, realistically, is most roles. Do not be talked into treating it as a misunderstanding, and be especially wary of an explanation that arrives only after you raise it.

Harassment, violence, or safety findings. A confirmed finding of harassment, bullying, assault or serious safety violation is not a fit issue. Hiring past it exposes your existing staff to a known risk and exposes you to liability for having known. There is no version of probation that manages this.

Fabricated referees. If a “manager” turns out to be a friend or a relative, the interview is over. This is not embellishment; it is a deliberate attempt to defeat your verification process, and it tells you everything about how this person will handle a rule they find inconvenient. It is more common than people think — which is why you should call the company switchboard rather than a mobile number the candidate provided.

A dismissal presented as a resignation. Discovering that a candidate was dismissed when their CV says they resigned is a material misrepresentation.

Material discrepancies in dates or position. A month’s difference is a memory problem. A year is not. A “Financial Manager” who was a creditors clerk is not misremembering. As with CVs generally, the concern is less the underlying fact than what the misstatement tells you about the rest of the document.

Abscondment. Someone who simply stopped arriving, without notice or explanation, has demonstrated a way of handling difficulty. Worth asking about — there are real explanations, including medical crises and genuinely unsafe workplaces — but it needs a satisfactory answer, not a vague one.

The same serious concern from independent referees. One referee raising a concern is a data point. Two unconnected employers describing the same behaviour is a pattern, and patterns predict.

A qualification the person does not hold. Where the role legally or practically requires a credential and verification shows it does not exist, that is the end of it. As covered elsewhere in this series, misrepresenting a registered qualification is now a criminal offence in South Africa.

Holding the line on process

Two practical points that make the difference between a rigorous check and a decorative one.

Verify who you are speaking to. Call the main switchboard and ask for the person by name and title. A supplied mobile number is not verification, and this single step catches most fabricated references.

Ask the closing question every time. “Is there anything else I should know before we make an offer?” It is remarkable how often a referee who has been carefully neutral for fifteen minutes will use that opening to say the thing they were not sure they were allowed to volunteer.

Where this leaves the series

Reference checking done properly is not a search for reasons to say no, and it is not a formality to be waved through. It is an attempt to build an accurate picture of a person from imperfect sources.

That means being generous about style, context and personality — because those are contested, contextual, and frequently say more about the referee than the candidate.

And it means being immovable about conduct, dishonesty and safety — because those are matters of record, they transfer between employers, and no amount of good intention on your part will manage them away.

Need help finding — and properly vetting — your next hire? RESOURCE Recruitment has been placing quality candidates with KZN employers since 2002, and our RESOURCEful Background Checks division can verify qualifications, criminal records, credit history, and references before you make the offer. Get in touch at www.2r.co.za.

 

Reading a Reference Check: Separating Fact from Opinion

Reading a Reference Check: Separating Fact from Opinion

Reading a Reference Check: Separating Fact from Opinion

Part one of three on getting real value out of reference checks.

At RESOURCE recruitment we conduct telephonic reference checks on every candidate we place. They are competency-based and we work hard to keep them fair and consistent.

But a reference is a conversation with a human being about another human being, and no amount of structure removes the subjectivity from that entirely.

This is not a reason to stop doing references. It is a reason to read them properly. And reading them properly starts with knowing which parts of a reference are facts you can rely on, and which parts are one person’s view.

The factual layer

Some items in a reference are verifiable. They exist in a personnel file, and the person giving the reference is either reporting them accurately or not.

  • Dates of employment — when the person started and when they left.
  • Position held, and whether the title matches what the candidate claimed.
  • Reason for termination as recorded by the employer — resignation, retrenchment, dismissal, contract end.
  • Whether formal disciplinary action was taken, and on what grounds, as recorded in their personnel file.
  • Whether the employer would re-employ the person.

These carry weight. Not because the referee is necessarily objective, but because they are matters of record — and often obtained from the payroll/ HR Department from the Employee records. A recorded reason for leaving that contradicts what the candidate told you is a genuine, checkable discrepancy.

The subjective layer

Then there is everything else. How they got on with the team. Whether they took feedback well. Whether they were a self-starter. Whether they were “a good fit”.  Whether they would reemploy them.  Even if there were any honesty issues (which did not warrant disciplinary action).

This material is not worthless. Sometimes it is the most useful part of the call. But it is one person’s perception and opinion, formed in a particular working relationship, and it needs to be weighed rather than simply recorded and taken as fact.

When I hear something negative in this layer, I want to know three things before I attach any weight to it.

Who is speaking? A direct line manager who worked with the person daily is a different source from an HR representative reading off a file, who is different again from a business owner the candidate resigned on. Each has a different vantage point and a different set of interests.

How specific is it? “He was difficult” is not usable information. “He pushed back publicly in meetings when decisions were made without consulting the team” is concrete, it describes actual behaviour, and it might be a problem or it might be exactly what you need, depending on your environment.

Does it recur? A single negative comment from one referee is a data point. The same concern from two independent referees is a pattern, and patterns are what you should act on.

Keep it in proportion

One last point, and it is the important one.

A reference is a single slice of a much larger picture. Where the role warrants it, you also have criminal checks, credit checks, qualification verification, psychometric assessment and a second interview available to you. Each of those tells you something a reference cannot.

No hiring decision should turn on one phone call with one person who may or may not have had a good working relationship with your candidate.

In the next post, I look at the reasons a genuinely good candidate can come away with a poor reference — and why it happens more often than most employers realise.

This article is general information, not legal advice. For specific situations, consult a labour law practitioner.

Hiring right the first time is still the best probation strategy of all. RESOURCE Recruitment has been matching KZN employers with quality, properly vetted candidates since 2002 — and our RESOURCEful Background Checks division verifies qualifications, references, and records before you sign that contract. 

 

 

 

How to Read a Credit Report When You Are Hiring

How to Read a Credit Report When You Are Hiring

How to Read a Credit Report When You Are Hiring

A practical guide for employers: when you may run a credit check, what the terms actually mean, and which findings are genuinely relevant to the role.

We run credit checks as part of our screening service, and the question I am asked most often by employers is not how to obtain one. It is what to do with it once they have it.

That question has become much harder to answer since 2020. A great many otherwise excellent, honest people came out of the pandemic years with judgments and defaults on their records. Businesses closed. Salaries were cut. Payment arrangements collapsed. The result is that adverse listings are now common enough that treating any listing as an automatic disqualification would rule out a substantial share of the working population.

First: are you actually allowed to run the check?

This is where most employers go wrong, and it happens before anyone reads a single line of a report.

You may not run a credit check on every candidate as a matter of routine. Regulation 19(12) of the National Credit Regulations restricts access to consumer credit records in the employment context. A credit record may only be accessed where the requestor certifies that the request relates to a position requiring honesty in the handling of cash or finances.

And there is a second requirement that is very frequently missed: before giving that certification, you must have a job description in place which states that the position requires honesty in the handling of cash or finances. The responsibility has to be written into the role, not assumed after the fact.

You also need the candidate’s consent, obtained before the report is requested.

The consequence of getting this wrong is worth understanding clearly. If the role does not genuinely involve handling cash or finances, the candidate’s consent does not make the check lawful. Consent is necessary but it is not sufficient. The National Credit Regulator enforces this provision and can investigate a certification and the job description behind it.

There is a further exposure. Under the Employment Equity Act, a job applicant is treated as an employee for purposes of unfair discrimination claims. A candidate who is rejected on the basis of a credit check that had no bearing on the role has a route to challenge that decision.

Understanding what you are looking at

Assuming you are entitled to the report, the terminology matters, because the various entries sit on very different rungs of seriousness. People use “blacklisted” as though it were one thing. It is not.

Payment profile

The month-by-month record of whether accounts were paid on time. This is the most useful and most overlooked part of the report. It shows behaviour over time rather than a single moment, and it distinguishes a person who hit one bad patch from a person who is consistently unreliable.

Default listing

The credit provider has reported that the account fell significantly behind and reasonable efforts to recover it did not succeed. More serious than arrears, but it is still a report by a creditor rather than a finding by anyone independent.

Handed over

The account has been transferred to a collections agency or attorney. This tells you the account was not resolved and reached the recovery stage. It is a step up in seriousness, but it is still not an adjudicated finding.

Judgment

A court has made an order against the person for the debt. This is the most serious of the ordinary listings, because a court has been involved and the person either did not defend the matter or defended it and lost.

Administration order and debt review

Both indicate formal steps to manage over-indebtedness. Counter-intuitively, these are often positive signals in a screening context. Someone under debt review has acknowledged a problem, submitted to a structured repayment plan and is complying with it. That demonstrates precisely the responsibility you are trying to assess.

Sequestration

Insolvency proceedings. Significant, and worth understanding the circumstances behind — a failed business is a very different story from personal overspending, and for many roles the former is not a concern at all.

A framework for the decision

Rather than a pass mark, work through five questions.

What is the nature of the debt? Is it a clothing account, cell phone bill or micro-loan; or is it a bond or car finance?

How recent is it? A judgment from 2021 with a clean record since then describes someone who went through a hard period and recovered. A pattern of new defaults in the last six months describes current, ongoing pressure. Recency matters far more than volume.

Is there a pattern, or is there an event? One cluster of listings around a single date usually indicates a specific event — a retrenchment, an illness, a divorce, a business failure. Listings spread evenly across five years indicate a habit.

Is the person addressing it? Settled judgments, an active debt review, paid-up defaults, a payment arrangement in place. All of these tell you something meaningful.

Does the risk map to the role? This is the one that should carry the most weight. Someone who is over-indebted and will be handling cash daily, unsupervised, presents a real and specific risk. The same person in a role with no financial exposure presents none at all.

Where employers get it wrong

  • Treating any adverse listing as automatic disqualification. Post-2020 this excludes a large share of good candidates and is disproportionate to the actual risk.
  • Running checks on roles that do not qualify. Common, unlawful, and increasingly likely to be challenged.
  • Reading the report without discussing it. Reports contain errors, and many judgments are taken by default without the person’s knowledge.
  • Confusing financial difficulty with dishonesty. They are not the same, and a credit report is poor evidence of the second.
  • Using the report as the decision rather than as one input. It belongs alongside references, criminal checks, qualification verification and the interview — not above them.

Have the conversation

If something adverse appears and the role genuinely warrants the check, raise it with the candidate before you decide.

Most people will explain readily — a business that closed in 2020, a medical bill, a co-signed loan for a family member who defaulted, an account they genuinely did not know had been handed over. Some will tell you it is an error, and sometimes they will be right.

What you learn from that conversation is usually worth more than the report itself. How someone accounts for a difficult period, whether they are straightforward about it, and what they have done since tells you a great deal about the person you are considering employing.

And that, ultimately, is what you were trying to find out.

Whether you’re job hunting right now or future-proofing your career, RESOURCE Recruitment is here to help. We’ve been connecting KZN job seekers with great employers since 2002 — browse our latest vacancies here